The secret to the best baked potato recipe is making baked potatoes that have a delicious salty, crispy outside skin that you and your family are going to want to eat! This is how most restaurants make their oven baked potatoes.
Just look at the photo below and take in the splendor that a crispy baked potato skin is. This is the perfect recipe, a crispy edible potato skin exterior that is left after you scoop out that fluffy, butter-soaked potato interior. This is one of the best side dishes you can make!
How to Make a Baked Potato: The Basics
You would think that baking a simple potato wouldn’t have so many questions around it, but like anything else in cooking and baking, there are factors that affect the best way to make them! Here are a few basics for baking potatoes that will help you make the best tones ever!
Did you know?
A baked potato is also called a jacket potato and they are the same thing. They are both potatoes baked in the oven or BBQ even until they are soft and fluffy inside.
- When the potato is properly cooked, you are going to have a crisp outside and soft inside that fluffs up perfectly when you take a fork to it.
- The true measure of a good baked potato is that you don’t need all of the fixings on top – the ones I make in this recipe were so good with just butter on them. We will get into types of potatoes that will affect your results below!
- They always take longer to cook than you think they are going to. Every single time. There are many variables when it comes to baking potatoes, such as size, shape, water content of each potato that you are going to have to be flexible. with your time.
- You don’t want to wrap your potatoes in tinfoil. That’s an okay way to bake them over a campfire to protect the skins from burning but they skin won’t crisp up.
What is the BEST baked potato recipe?
I am going to claim that this recipe is one of the best because I had a lot of advice from chefs that know their stuff! Not that *I* don’t know my stuff, (because most times I do!) but it really helps to have my opinion confirmed by professionals. Olive oil can make potatoes a wee bit bitter. In this world where everyone slathers olive oil on everything because it’s healthier, we forget that it also adds flavor and a quite bitter one at that. So that’s what sets my recipe apart from the others, and it really does make a difference you guys!
How do I clean a potato before I bake it?
Cleaning a potato before you bake it in the oven is super easy! I know that some people can get grossed out looking at the dirt on the skin of a potato, but if the dark coloring remains after you clean it, it’s simply a stain in the skin and not dirt! To clean and prepare a potato for baking you need to:
- Wash the potato under cool running water and gently scrub the dirt off. Try not to remove the skin by scrubbing too hard, we want the skin to remain!
- Dry gently with a paper towel, again, trying not to remove the outer layer of skin. Pat with paper towels until the potato is dry. You want the potato to be dry so that when you rub the oil on it, it will absorb into the skin better.
- Pierce with a fork a few times ( see below why this is important.)
- Follow the remaining recipe instructions.
What Type of Potato Works Best for Baked Potatoes?
This is the real question of the day! Here is a small overview of the types of potatoes and their uses:
- Starchy potatoes such as Idaho and Russets: These are your very best choice for baking as they are high in starch and low in moisture, making them light and fluffy once cooked and absorbent (that means they are going to just soak up that butter!)
- All-purpose potatoes ( example:Yukon Gold): Good for roasting, mashing or baking.
- Waxy potatoes ( example:red-skinned potatoes): Red potatoes are the best for soups and salads because they hold their shape after being cooked. There are many recipes that boil then smash red potatoes, so they are also great for crashed potatoes as well!
How do I make a quick baked potato?
There is a trick to making fast baked potatoes that aren’t quite as good as fully baked but will still finish in the oven, and that’s using your microwave to start out the cooking process fast. This does remove about 50 minutes of baking time!
- Pre-heat your oven to 400 °F.
- Microwave 2-3 clean, fork-pierced potatoes for 4-5 minutes ( depending on size). Remove carefully and place on baking sheet . Brush them with olive oil all over, then sprinkle with sea salt.
- Bake in the oven for 10-15 minutes until the potato is tender enough to be pierced with a fork easily.
- Cut a slit in the top of the potato and push the ends inward to open up. Serve and enjoy.
Do I bake potatoes with or without foil? Is foil faster?
It is thought that baking potatoes in foil speeds up the cooking process, but for my crispy skinned potatoes, you must leave the foil off. If you enjoy potatoes that are soft skinned, then you will wrap them in foil and bake them to achieve that result. However this is all about getting that salty, crispy potato skin on the outside that is so darn amazing!
How to Make a Baked Potato in the Oven
- Preheat your oven to 400 °F.
- Pierce each potato 3-4 times with the tines of a fork.
- Coat each one well in canola oil, then sprinkle heavily with flaked sea salt all over. You need to get a good crust of salt.
- Place on a wire baking rack in the middle of a baking tray and place the potatoes on top.
- Bake in the oven for 60-75 minutes or until they are fork tender. Remove and cool slightly on the baking sheet.
How to Make a Baked Potato in the Microwave
Microwave baked potatoes will NOT have that amazing crispy exterior that most people are looking for in their baked potatoes but let me tell you, when you are pressed for time making baked potatoes in the microwave is the best time saving trick ever!
- Take the cleaned potatoes and pierce with a fork several times. Place them on a plate and if you are lucky enough to have a baked potato button on your microwave, use it and choose the correct amount of potatoes.
- If you don’t have that option on your microwave, microwave the potatoes on high for 6-7 minutes to start, then carefully turn them over. Microwave in additional 3 minute intervals until the potato is fork tender when pierced.
Why would a baked potato explode in the oven? Do I have to pierce them?
Baked potatoes can explode when steam builds up within them. This is the reason why piercing them with a fork is incredibly important before cooking in the oven or microwave. In fact, it’s not even the oven that you need to be worried about ( other than a mess to clean up!) I have heard it from chefs that potatoes can explode AFTER you take them out of the oven – and potatoes have exploded on chefs. Ouch. Pierce the potatoes for safety’s sake!
Some More Delicious Potato Recipes From My Website
Here are some of my favourite potato recipes on this website, from soups to salads to main dishes! We love a good feast of potatoes!
- Classic German Potato Salad
- Rosemary Garlic Smashed Potatoes
- Cheesy Bacon Potato Soup
- Sweet Mustard Sausage and Potato Skillet
- Easy Potato Leek Soup
- Mini Loaded Smashed Potato Bites
- Creamy Potato and Hamburger Soup
How to Cut and Serve a Baked Potato
- To serve, once they are warm cut a slit lengthwise down the top of the potato, not cutting to the very end however.
- Take your fingers and place on either side of the potato and push the ends in towards each other to “pop” the center open ( it will look like a restaurant potato now!)
- Serve with baked potato toppings listed below
Baked Potato Toppings
- Serve with butter, salt and pepper
- Sour Cream
- Green onions or chives
- Seasoning Salt
- Bacon bits ( homemade diced bacon is the best
- Shredded cheese – try Tex-Mex for a great flavour boost
What to Serve with Baked Potatoes
Serve these baked potatoes with steak using my Steak Marinade recipe or my Amazing BBQ ribs. We also love to make my BBQ Root Beer Slow Cooker Brisket which is my favourite brisket recipe ever! You can also try my Red Wine and Bacon Braised Beef Short Ribs. my lemon grilled salmon or my mushroom chuck roast recipe!
Karlynn’s Tips & Tricks for Making the Best Baked Potato
- Use canola oil. Yes, I know that everyone uses olive oil but here’s a secret: restaurants know that olive oil can give high-temperature baked goods a slightly (or quite) bitter taste sometimes. More than one of my professional chef friends have sworn up and down this is how you make potatoes that are crispy and not bitter. Too easy, right? It can depend on the quality of the oil, how long it’s in the oven but the best way is to use a neutral flavoured oil for the best taste possible. Buy a nice cold-pressed canola oil and see how amazing it is! Here is a really good, seemingly non-biased article on canola oil, it’s very enlightening.
- Bake these on a wire rack to get the air circulation under the potatoes as well.
- Allow yourself extra time. I laugh at recipes that tell you potatoes are baked in 45 minutes – never, ever have I been able to do it! I don’t know what’s wrong with me, but mine take a solid 60-75 minutes every single time.
- Sea salt is going to rock your world on these potatoes. We demolished the potato skins like a pack of wolves and the skins are where most of the nutrients are!
- While these baked potatoes are really good loaded up with everything like sour cream, bacon and cheese, I do beg you to try these with just some butter and pepper. Not only does it keep the calorie count down if that’s a concern, it really allows you to enjoy the actual flavour of the potato and skin. Plain, simple and delicious.
Happy (baked potato) baking!
Love,
Karlynn
How to Make Salty, Crispy Skinned Oven Baked Potatoes
Ingredients
- 4 medium/large russet potatoes scrubbed well
- 4 tablespoons cold pressed canola oil or other neutral flavoured oil
- 4 tablespoons flaked sea salt
Instructions
- Preheat your oven to 400 °F.
- Pierce each potato 3-4 times with the tines of a fork.
- Coat each one well in canola oil, then sprinkle heavily with flaked sea salt all over. You need to get a good crust of salt. Place on a wire baking rack in the middle of a baking tray and place the potatoes on top.
- Bake in the oven for 60-75 minutes or until they are fork tender. Remove and cool slightly on the baking sheet.
- To serve, once they are warm cut a slit lengthwise down the top of the potato, not cutting to the very end however. Take your fingers and place on either side of the potato and push the ends in towards each other to “pop” the center open ( it will look like a restaurant potato now!)
- Serve with butter and pepper, or any and all toppings!
Video
Notes
Tips & Tricks
- Use canola oil. Yes, I know that everyone uses olive oil but here’s a secret: restaurants know that olive oil can give high-temperature baked goods a slightly (or quite) bitter taste sometimes. More than one of my professional chef friends have sworn up and down this is how you make potatoes that are crispy and not bitter. Too easy, right? It can depend on the quality of the oil, how long it’s in the oven but the best way is to use a neutral flavoured oil for the best taste possible. Buy a nice cold-pressed canola oil and see how amazing it is! Here is a really good, seemingly non-biased article on canola oil, it’s very enlightening.
- Bake these on a wire rack to get the air circulation under the potatoes as well.
- Allow yourself extra time. I laugh at recipes that tell you potatoes are baked in 45 minutes – never, ever have I been able to do it! I don’t know what’s wrong with me, but mine take a solid 60-75 minutes every single time.
- Sea salt is going to rock your world on these potatoes. We demolished the potato skins like a pack of wolves and the skins are where most of the nutrients are!
- While these baked potatoes are really good loaded up with everything like sour cream, bacon and cheese, I do beg you to try these with just some butter and pepper. Not only does it keep the calorie count down if that’s a concern, it really allows you to enjoy the actual flavour of the potato and skin. Plain, simple and delicious.
Nutrition
Pin This Recipe to your Side Dishes & Appetizers Boards and Remember to FOLLOW ME ON PINTEREST!
Lori says
I made these tonight and followed the recipe to the letter. The skins did not get crisp and they were so salty that they over salted everything else on the plate. I love salt-crusted potatoes in restaurants usually, but these didn’t work.
Liz says
Great tasting crispy skin with moist potato!!! I bragged about it so much I he family has ne making them part of our New Year’s Eve dinner☺️thank you
Ella says
If you “love salt crusted potatoes” then how could these be too salty for you? Salt crusted literally means crusted in salt. It is virtually impossible to love salt crusted and feel they are too salty.
As for the skins not getting crispy I’ll bet dollars to donuts you oiled your potatoes while wet or still damp from washing. That is about the only way that would happen, so user error on your part.
Polarisking says
Measured in the thickest part of the potato, 205° will guarantee doneness.
Alicia says
Totally agree about olive oil, but since canola oil oxidizes when heated, I would only use it in raw form for salad dressings; Sunflower and Rice Bran Oil are better choices when heating at any temperature. I even make fried donuts with Sunflower or Rice Bran Oil, never heat canola oil, not even in a cake, because it has an off-putting taste. Sunflower and Rice Bran Oils are high heat oils that give no added flavor.
JC says
I have been baking potatoes the wrong way for 40 years! Using canola oil and Maldives Sea Salt Flakes make a world of difference! My husband and I both thought the potatoes were delicious. Thank you for sharing this recipe.
Sherry says
Can these be made the day before and just reheated?
Violet Smith says
Nice write up. You may want to edit your recipe to include scallions. I agree with simple, quality butter and salt. But I’d miss the scallions and they are in the photos you use to go with your content.
Mickey Hansman says
In fact no matter if someone doesn’t know then its up to other visitors that they will assist, so here it occurs.|
Karissa Stearns says
So the secret to cooking baked potatoes in 45 minutes, nuke them in the microwave for 5 min to soften them a bit. There is absolutely no shame there and you still get all the benefits of the oven baked potato and flavor. It just makes the process of oven cooked bakers quicker. I actually only do about a half hour in the oven.
Cait says
Hi! In the quick version you say to use olive oil, but further down you say use canola oil. Which one should I use?
Christa S says
Wooo! 291% of your daily sodium? I think I’ll search for a lighter salt recipe.
Alicia says
Brush off the excess salt after baking onto a plate, then pinch what you want in the center of the baked potato as you eat it.
Sandy says
Best potato. Bake, don’t microwave. Bake to a temperature of 205 degrees Fahrenheit. Love fluffy potatoes.
Jane Newberry says
I make mine this way and they are delicious!! I skip the fattening butter, toppings and put A-1 sauce on top. Tastes fantastic and only 15 calories per tablespoon!
Clarissa Hoover says
Can we travel 15 minutes with them and somehow keep them crispy?
Alicia says
Yes, just don’t cover them with anything, because that will trap steam and cause a softer skin.
Boo says
You keep your dinner table 15 minutes away? Just move it closer and you will be fine.
Ginny says
First thing- yes on the canola oil. Olive oil is best fresh and not heated and yes it gets bitter. Why do do many baked potato recipes use it? Why ruin a tasty baked potato? Second thing- AMEN TO THE CRUNCHY SEA SALT SISTER. Third thing- thank you for being real about the baking time. My potatoes take twice the time to cook and I don’t know why but I hate when recipes tell you they are 45 minutes. Mine are always crunchy still. These are my go to for summer now, Magpie you rock as always.
Mr. Kitchen Magpie says
Thanks for letting us know! I make these baked potatoes with steak during the summer, so easy!
Alicia says
Your altitude makes a difference in how long it takes to bake or boil foods. I am at 3300 ft. elevation, so I’m always using my trusty fork to know when a baked potato is ready.
Deborah Schomer says
These potatoes are amazing, the best I’ve ever tasted! Thank you.
Alison French-Tubo says
These were delicious with our Christmas dinner, thanks.
Mr. Kitchen Magpie says
Glad you liked them!
Bev Ross says
I love baked potatoes. These sound so amazing I can’t wait to try them. I just have to buy the flaked sea salt. And the baking potatoes!
You’ve made my day!
Karlynn says
I hope you love them!!
Mother of 3 says
Those look delicious! I don’t typically think of starting my baked potatoes in the microwave but I love how much time that saves. Pinned.
Spire says
“Why You Shouldn’t Microwave
A microwave might seem like a fast way to “bake” a potato, but we found two reasons why it’s actually the worst approach. First, microwaves heat foods very unevenly, so some parts of the potato might rapidly reach 205 degrees while others get to only 180 degrees. Second, rapidly heating a potato causes pressure to build and cell walls to burst, releasing starch molecules that glue together the broken cell walls.”
Jen says
One stop shop for all I need to know! Pinning!!
Sandra | A Dash of Sanity says
I need to try this! Thanks for all the tips!
Jocelyn (Grandbaby Cakes) says
This is seriously such a great post!!! Loving it!
Allyson Zea says
Baked potatoes are my weakness! Love these crispy skins!
Delaney | Melanie Makes says
I love a good baked potato!
Nutmeg Nanny says
Love this! Thanks for sharing!
Meghan @ Cake 'n Knife says
I’m so loving this guide! Canola oil is totally the way to go!
Karlynn Johnston says
It IS! That’s why the potatoes in restaurants taste SO good, the natural potato flavour is all you taste, not olive oil!
Tanya says
I’ve made salt-baked potatoes in a crockpot before – put an inch of coarse salt in the bottom, pierce the potatoes and lightly coat in oil, then place in the crockpot and cover completely with more salt. Pierce the salt crust when done and the salt can be re-used; the best home-cooked potatoes I’ve ever tasted.
Karlynn Johnston says
Those sound sooo good!
Jill says
Can I use another kind of poatato for these?
Karlynn Johnston says
You can use anything called “baking potato” on the package or labelled in the store. Those are the best for making baked potatoes.
KentuckyBill says
ten out of ten!!! This is my go to recipe from now on, thank you!
Karlynn Johnston says
Great to hear! Thanks for telling me!
BonniM says
These are like Red Lobster’s Salty potatoes!! HA! NOW I know how to make them at home! You area genius!
YuYuG says
That’s where I have seen them, these are like their salt crusted potatoes that we love at red lobster. So the secret is canola or vegetable, right? Can I use something like peanut?
April says
These were awesome, thanks Karlynne!
Karlynn Johnston says
Always glad to help!
Linda says
Hi, this sounds great and so easy! One question, in the instructions you talk about canola oil, but, on the recipe card you use olive oil. Which do you prefer? Thanks
Karlynn Johnston says
THANK YOU for catching that! My mind says one thing and my fingers type another, it happens all the time! Canola oil ALL the way!